The Psychology of Fantasy Villains: Why We’re Drawn to Characters Like Sauron

Villains have long captivated audiences within the fantasy genre, serving as complex mirrors reflecting the darker facets of human nature. In The Rings of Power, Sauron emerges as a particularly compelling antagonist. His multifaceted portrayal—from the enigmatic figure of Halbrand to the manipulative 'Lord of Gifts', Annatar—transcends the traditional embodiment of evil, inviting an exploration of the psychological underpinnings that draw us to such characters.

​Sauron's transformation throughout the first two seasons offers a nuanced study in psychological manipulation and the allure of power. Key moments—such as Halbrand's interactions with Galadriel and the subtle revelations hinting at his true identity—underscore his cunning and charisma. These scenes are not merely pivotal narrative devices but resonate on a deeper psychological level, engaging viewers in a dialogue about trust, ambition, and the susceptibility of individuals to persuasive forces.

​​Generated with DALL·E.

​The Allure of Malignant Narcissism and Power

​Sauron's ability to captivate stems from his embodiment of malignant narcissism. Unlike conventional depictions of evil that rely on overt domination, he seduces others by presenting himself as a partner and saviour. His guise as Halbrand allows him to tap into the desires and vulnerabilities of characters like Galadriel, making them more amenable to his influence.

​A particularly memorable scene is when Halbrand, sensing Galadriel's isolation and determination, tells her, "Sometimes to find the light, we must first touch the darkness." This line reflects his skill in exploiting ambition under the guise of empathy and shared purpose.

​Another memorable scene is Annatar’s interaction with Celebrimbor in Episode 6 of Season 2, where he flattered and encouraged the elvish smith into forging the Nine Rings. His dialogue—“Your rings…will be deemed the most precious creations in all Middle-Earth”—reflects his ability to exploit ambition under the guise of encouragement.

Sauron Getting in Celebrimbor's Head

​Psychologically, this dynamic mirrors real-world encounters with manipulative individuals who utilize charm and feigned understanding to achieve their ends. Sauron's actions highlight the dangers of unchecked ego and ambition, forcing both characters and viewers to confront their vulnerabilities. His manipulation serves as a cautionary tale about the ease with which one can be led astray by persuasive rhetoric and the promise of fulfilling deeply held desires.

​​Generated with DALL·E.

Deception as a Psychological Weapon

​Sauron’s mastery of deception is unparalleled, skillfully employed to control perceptions and realities throughout the series. The gradual unveiling of his true nature underscores the sophistication of his manipulative tactics. One of the most striking examples is the pivotal scene in Episode 7 of Season 2, where Celebrimbor finally unravels Annatar’s illusion and realizes the truth: Annatar is Sauron. Similarly, the moment when Galadriel begins to suspect Halbrand's true identity is laden with psychological tension, compelling both her—and the audience—to reevaluate previously held assumptions.

​In the scene with Celebrimbor, Sauron’s control over his reality is symbolized by details like unchanged candles and an eerie stillness. Celebrimbor’s growing doubts culminate in a confrontation, with Sauron justifying his actions: “True creation requires sacrifice.” This moment encapsulates Sauron’s ability to frame his manipulation as a noble act. Likewise, Halbrand's knowledge of ancient lore and smithing techniques raises Galadriel's suspicions. Her internal struggle is evident as she grapples with the possibility that her ally may, in fact, be her greatest enemy.

​These revelations are not solely about unmasking Sauron, but also about the introspection and recognition of personal complicity by both Galadriel and Celebrimbor. Their ambition and desires—Galadriel's for vengeance and Celebrimbor's for creation—blinded them to the warning signs, illustrating how personal motivations can obscure judgment. Sauron's subtle assertion, "You believed in me because you needed to," serves as a stark reminder of how individual desires can be manipulated to serve nefarious ends.

Celebrimbor Finally Knows Annatar is Sauron

​The Moment of Realization

The psychological unraveling of trust is one of the most compelling aspects of The Rings of Power. In Episode 7, Celebrimbor’s epiphany highlights the subtle cues Sauron used to maintain his control. As the illusion crumbles, Celebrimbor confronts his own role in allowing Sauron’s deception to take root.

​Sauron’s statement—“You welcomed my instruction; you practically begged for it”—is a brutal reminder of how ambition can overshadow caution. This moment is a powerful commentary on the dynamics of exploitation, where trust and aspiration are weaponized against the victim.

​The Seduction of Treachery

​One of the reasons Sauron remains a captivating villain is his ability to weave influence through calculated relationships and betrayals. From his interactions with Galadriel in Season 1 to his manipulation of Celebrimbor in Season 2, his treachery is both unpredictable and enthralling.

​The Season 1 scene where Halbrand reveals himself to Galadriel exemplifies this. His line—“You need me”—reflects how he embeds himself into others’ lives, making them question their own instincts and decisions. This climactic revelation similarly challenges Galadriel’s perception of reality. Halbrand’s line, "I have been awake since before the breaking of the first silence. In that time, I have had many names," not only unravels his true identity but also forces Galadriel to reassess her understanding of good and evil. This reflects the psychological concept of betrayal trauma, where the violation of trust by a close confidant leads to profound emotional and cognitive dissonance.

Halbrand Reveals Himself to Galadriel

​This theme continues in his interactions with Celebrimbor, where his subtle pressures and grand promises disguise his true motives. It’s a reflection of real-world dynamics where betrayal often stems from those we trust most.

Celebrimbor Sides with Annatar

Sauron’s Shadow and the Attraction of Darkness

​Villains like Sauron allow us to safely explore the darker sides of our psyche. Carl Jung's concept of the 'shadow self' refers to the unconscious parts of ourselves that we suppress or deny. Sauron embodies these repressed aspects—ruthlessness, cunning, and an insatiable lust for control.

​Through his manipulation of Galadriel, Celebrimbor, and others, Sauron serves as a mirror to our own vulnerabilities. His actions force us to consider the consequences of giving in to ambition and ego, providing a space to confront the darker aspects of human nature. Engaging with his character enables viewers to acknowledge these suppressed traits within themselves, fostering a deeper understanding of the complexities of human behaviour.

​​Generated with DALL·E.

Final Thoughts: The Enduring Appeal of Fantasy Villains

​The portrayal of Sauron in The Rings of Power offers a rich narrative that resonates on multiple levels. His transformation from Halbrand to Annatar, his manipulation of Galadriel and Celebrimbor, and the gradual revelation of his true identity showcase his unparalleled skill in deception and control. These interactions are not only entertaining but also deeply introspective, challenging us to examine our own susceptibilities.

​Sauron's story serves as a cautionary tale about the perils of unchecked ambition and misplaced trust, reminding us of the delicate balance between light and darkness within us all. As the series continues, it promises to delve even deeper into his evolution. If the first two seasons are any indication, his journey will continue to challenge our understanding of morality, power, and the 'shadow self'.

​Villains like Sauron endure in the fantasy genre because they compel us to reflect on the inherent complexities of good and evil. By confronting the shadows within ourselves through these characters, we gain insights into our own nature and the world around us.